Logo
-

Byte Open Security

(ByteOS Network)

Log In

Sign Up

ByteOS

Security
Vulnerability Details
Registries
Custom Views
Weaknesses
Attack Patterns
Filters & Tools
Vulnerability Details :

CVE-2016-4426

Summary
Assigner-redhat
Assigner Org ID-53f830b8-0a3f-465b-8143-3b8a9948e749
Published At-28 Jul, 2022 | 16:31
Updated At-06 Aug, 2024 | 00:32
Rejected At-
Credits

In zulip before 1.3.12, bot API keys were accessible to other users in the same realm.

Vendors
-
Not available
Products
-
Metrics (CVSS)
VersionBase scoreBase severityVector
Weaknesses
Attack Patterns
Solution/Workaround
References
HyperlinkResource Type
EPSS History
Score
Latest Score
-
N/A
No data available for selected date range
Percentile
Latest Percentile
-
N/A
No data available for selected date range
Stakeholder-Specific Vulnerability Categorization (SSVC)
▼Common Vulnerabilities and Exposures (CVE)
cve.org
Assigner:redhat
Assigner Org ID:53f830b8-0a3f-465b-8143-3b8a9948e749
Published At:28 Jul, 2022 | 16:31
Updated At:06 Aug, 2024 | 00:32
Rejected At:
▼CVE Numbering Authority (CNA)

In zulip before 1.3.12, bot API keys were accessible to other users in the same realm.

Affected Products
Vendor
n/a
Product
zulip
Versions
Affected
  • zulip 1.3.12
Problem Types
TypeCWE IDDescription
CWECWE-284CWE-284
Type: CWE
CWE ID: CWE-284
Description: CWE-284
Metrics
VersionBase scoreBase severityVector
Metrics Other Info
Impacts
CAPEC IDDescription
Solutions

Configurations

Workarounds

Exploits

Credits

Timeline
EventDate
Replaced By

Rejected Reason

References
HyperlinkResource
https://zulip.readthedocs.io/en/2.1.7/overview/changelog.html#id35
x_refsource_MISC
Hyperlink: https://zulip.readthedocs.io/en/2.1.7/overview/changelog.html#id35
Resource:
x_refsource_MISC
▼Authorized Data Publishers (ADP)
CVE Program Container
Affected Products
Metrics
VersionBase scoreBase severityVector
Metrics Other Info
Impacts
CAPEC IDDescription
Solutions

Configurations

Workarounds

Exploits

Credits

Timeline
EventDate
Replaced By

Rejected Reason

References
HyperlinkResource
https://zulip.readthedocs.io/en/2.1.7/overview/changelog.html#id35
x_refsource_MISC
x_transferred
Hyperlink: https://zulip.readthedocs.io/en/2.1.7/overview/changelog.html#id35
Resource:
x_refsource_MISC
x_transferred
Information is not available yet
▼National Vulnerability Database (NVD)
nvd.nist.gov
Source:secalert@redhat.com
Published At:28 Jul, 2022 | 17:15
Updated At:04 Aug, 2022 | 17:36

In zulip before 1.3.12, bot API keys were accessible to other users in the same realm.

CISA Catalog
Date AddedDue DateVulnerability NameRequired Action
N/A
Date Added: N/A
Due Date: N/A
Vulnerability Name: N/A
Required Action: N/A
Metrics
TypeVersionBase scoreBase severityVector
Primary3.14.3MEDIUM
CVSS:3.1/AV:N/AC:L/PR:L/UI:N/S:U/C:L/I:N/A:N
Type: Primary
Version: 3.1
Base score: 4.3
Base severity: MEDIUM
Vector:
CVSS:3.1/AV:N/AC:L/PR:L/UI:N/S:U/C:L/I:N/A:N
CPE Matches

Kandra Labs, Inc. (Zulip)
zulip
>>zulip>>Versions before 1.3.12(exclusive)
cpe:2.3:a:zulip:zulip:*:*:*:*:*:*:*:*
Weaknesses
CWE IDTypeSource
NVD-CWE-noinfoPrimarynvd@nist.gov
CWE-284Secondarysecalert@redhat.com
CWE ID: NVD-CWE-noinfo
Type: Primary
Source: nvd@nist.gov
CWE ID: CWE-284
Type: Secondary
Source: secalert@redhat.com
Evaluator Description

Evaluator Impact

Evaluator Solution

Vendor Statements

References
HyperlinkSourceResource
https://zulip.readthedocs.io/en/2.1.7/overview/changelog.html#id35secalert@redhat.com
Release Notes
Third Party Advisory
Hyperlink: https://zulip.readthedocs.io/en/2.1.7/overview/changelog.html#id35
Source: secalert@redhat.com
Resource:
Release Notes
Third Party Advisory

Change History

0
Information is not available yet

Similar CVEs

120Records found

CVE-2025-1606
Matching Score-4
Assigner-VulDB
ShareView Details
Matching Score-4
Assigner-VulDB
CVSS Score-5.3||MEDIUM
EPSS-0.05% / 16.66%
||
7 Day CHG~0.00%
Published-24 Feb, 2025 | 00:00
Updated-28 Feb, 2025 | 18:33
Rejected-Not Available
Known To Be Used In Ransomware Campaigns?-Not Available
KEV Added-Not Available
KEV Action Due Date-Not Available
SourceCodester Best Employee Management System backups.php information disclosure

A vulnerability classified as problematic was found in SourceCodester Best Employee Management System 1.0. This vulnerability affects unknown code of the file /admin/backup/backups.php. The manipulation leads to information disclosure. The attack can be initiated remotely. The exploit has been disclosed to the public and may be used. The vendor was contacted early about this disclosure but did not respond in any way.

Action-Not Available
Vendor-SourceCodestermayuri_k
Product-best_employee_management_systemBest Employee Management System
CWE ID-CWE-200
Exposure of Sensitive Information to an Unauthorized Actor
CWE ID-CWE-284
Improper Access Control
CVE-2025-0226
Matching Score-4
Assigner-VulDB
ShareView Details
Matching Score-4
Assigner-VulDB
CVSS Score-5.3||MEDIUM
EPSS-0.06% / 17.21%
||
7 Day CHG~0.00%
Published-05 Jan, 2025 | 17:31
Updated-06 Jan, 2025 | 14:34
Rejected-Not Available
Known To Be Used In Ransomware Campaigns?-Not Available
KEV Added-Not Available
KEV Action Due Date-Not Available
Tsinghua Unigroup Electronic Archives System downLoad.html download information disclosure

A vulnerability, which was classified as problematic, has been found in Tsinghua Unigroup Electronic Archives System 3.2.210802(62532). Affected by this issue is the function download of the file /collect/PortV4/downLoad.html. The manipulation of the argument path leads to information disclosure. The attack may be launched remotely. The exploit has been disclosed to the public and may be used.

Action-Not Available
Vendor-Tsinghua Unigroup
Product-Electronic Archives System
CWE ID-CWE-200
Exposure of Sensitive Information to an Unauthorized Actor
CWE ID-CWE-284
Improper Access Control
CVE-2025-0227
Matching Score-4
Assigner-VulDB
ShareView Details
Matching Score-4
Assigner-VulDB
CVSS Score-5.3||MEDIUM
EPSS-0.06% / 17.21%
||
7 Day CHG~0.00%
Published-05 Jan, 2025 | 18:00
Updated-06 Jan, 2025 | 15:49
Rejected-Not Available
Known To Be Used In Ransomware Campaigns?-Not Available
KEV Added-Not Available
KEV Action Due Date-Not Available
Tsinghua Unigroup Electronic Archives System downLoad.html information disclosure

A vulnerability, which was classified as problematic, was found in Tsinghua Unigroup Electronic Archives System 3.2.210802(62532). This affects an unknown part of the file /Logs/Annals/downLoad.html. The manipulation of the argument path leads to information disclosure. It is possible to initiate the attack remotely. The exploit has been disclosed to the public and may be used.

Action-Not Available
Vendor-Tsinghua Unigroup
Product-Electronic Archives System
CWE ID-CWE-200
Exposure of Sensitive Information to an Unauthorized Actor
CWE ID-CWE-284
Improper Access Control
CVE-2024-9298
Matching Score-4
Assigner-VulDB
ShareView Details
Matching Score-4
Assigner-VulDB
CVSS Score-5.3||MEDIUM
EPSS-0.04% / 10.25%
||
7 Day CHG~0.00%
Published-28 Sep, 2024 | 13:31
Updated-01 Oct, 2024 | 13:37
Rejected-Not Available
Known To Be Used In Ransomware Campaigns?-Not Available
KEV Added-Not Available
KEV Action Due Date-Not Available
SourceCodester Online Railway Reservation System Ticket ?page=tickets access control

A vulnerability was found in SourceCodester Online Railway Reservation System 1.0. It has been rated as problematic. Affected by this issue is some unknown functionality of the file /?page=tickets of the component Ticket Handler. The manipulation of the argument id leads to improper access controls. The attack may be launched remotely. The exploit has been disclosed to the public and may be used.

Action-Not Available
Vendor-oretnom23SourceCodester
Product-railway_reservation_systemOnline Railway Reservation System
CWE ID-CWE-284
Improper Access Control
CWE ID-CWE-639
Authorization Bypass Through User-Controlled Key
CVE-2024-9003
Matching Score-4
Assigner-VulDB
ShareView Details
Matching Score-4
Assigner-VulDB
CVSS Score-5.3||MEDIUM
EPSS-0.10% / 28.13%
||
7 Day CHG~0.00%
Published-19 Sep, 2024 | 21:00
Updated-25 Sep, 2024 | 17:18
Rejected-Not Available
Known To Be Used In Ransomware Campaigns?-Not Available
KEV Added-Not Available
KEV Action Due Date-Not Available
Jinan Chicheng Company JFlow Attachment EntityMutliFile_Load.do AttachmentUploadController access control

A vulnerability was found in Jinan Chicheng Company JFlow 2.0.0. It has been rated as problematic. This issue affects the function AttachmentUploadController of the file /WF/Ath/EntityMutliFile_Load.do of the component Attachment Handler. The manipulation of the argument oid leads to improper access controls. The attack may be initiated remotely. The exploit has been disclosed to the public and may be used. The vendor was contacted early about this disclosure but did not respond in any way.

Action-Not Available
Vendor-jflow_projectJinan Chicheng Companyjinan_chicheng_company
Product-jflowJFlowjflow
CWE ID-CWE-284
Improper Access Control
CVE-2022-0170
Matching Score-4
Assigner-Protect AI (formerly huntr.dev)
ShareView Details
Matching Score-4
Assigner-Protect AI (formerly huntr.dev)
CVSS Score-5.3||MEDIUM
EPSS-0.17% / 38.39%
||
7 Day CHG~0.00%
Published-11 Jan, 2022 | 15:20
Updated-02 Aug, 2024 | 23:18
Rejected-Not Available
Known To Be Used In Ransomware Campaigns?-Not Available
KEV Added-Not Available
KEV Action Due Date-Not Available
Improper Access Control in chocobozzz/peertube

peertube is vulnerable to Improper Access Control

Action-Not Available
Vendor-framasoftchocobozzz
Product-peertubechocobozzz/peertube
CWE ID-CWE-284
Improper Access Control
CVE-2022-0405
Matching Score-4
Assigner-Protect AI (formerly huntr.dev)
ShareView Details
Matching Score-4
Assigner-Protect AI (formerly huntr.dev)
CVSS Score-4.3||MEDIUM
EPSS-0.12% / 32.34%
||
7 Day CHG~0.00%
Published-03 Apr, 2022 | 18:30
Updated-19 Nov, 2024 | 13:55
Rejected-Not Available
Known To Be Used In Ransomware Campaigns?-Not Available
KEV Added-Not Available
KEV Action Due Date-Not Available
Improper Access Control in janeczku/calibre-web

Improper Access Control in GitHub repository janeczku/calibre-web prior to 0.6.16.

Action-Not Available
Vendor-janeczkujaneczku
Product-calibre-webjaneczku/calibre-web
CWE ID-CWE-284
Improper Access Control
CVE-2023-32062
Matching Score-4
Assigner-GitHub, Inc.
ShareView Details
Matching Score-4
Assigner-GitHub, Inc.
CVSS Score-5||MEDIUM
EPSS-0.19% / 41.66%
||
7 Day CHG~0.00%
Published-27 Nov, 2023 | 20:58
Updated-02 Aug, 2024 | 15:03
Rejected-Not Available
Known To Be Used In Ransomware Campaigns?-Not Available
KEV Added-Not Available
KEV Action Due Date-Not Available
OroCalendarBundle has incorrect system calendar events visibility

OroPlatform is a package that assists system and user calendar management. Back-office users can access information from any system calendar event, bypassing ACL security restrictions due to insufficient security checks. This vulnerability has been patched in version 5.1.1.

Action-Not Available
Vendor-oroincoroinc
Product-oroplatformcrm
CWE ID-CWE-284
Improper Access Control
CVE-2022-4810
Matching Score-4
Assigner-Protect AI (formerly huntr.dev)
ShareView Details
Matching Score-4
Assigner-Protect AI (formerly huntr.dev)
CVSS Score-6.3||MEDIUM
EPSS-0.05% / 14.16%
||
7 Day CHG~0.00%
Published-28 Dec, 2022 | 00:00
Updated-10 Apr, 2025 | 16:43
Rejected-Not Available
Known To Be Used In Ransomware Campaigns?-Not Available
KEV Added-Not Available
KEV Action Due Date-Not Available
Improper Access Control in usememos/memos

Improper Access Control in GitHub repository usememos/memos prior to 0.9.1.

Action-Not Available
Vendor-Usememos
Product-memosusememos/memos
CWE ID-CWE-284
Improper Access Control
CVE-2024-54038
Matching Score-4
Assigner-Adobe Systems Incorporated
ShareView Details
Matching Score-4
Assigner-Adobe Systems Incorporated
CVSS Score-4.3||MEDIUM
EPSS-0.10% / 27.63%
||
7 Day CHG+0.01%
Published-10 Dec, 2024 | 20:42
Updated-15 Jan, 2025 | 17:39
Rejected-Not Available
Known To Be Used In Ransomware Campaigns?-Not Available
KEV Added-Not Available
KEV Action Due Date-Not Available
Adobe Connect | Improper Access Control (CWE-284)

Adobe Connect versions 12.6, 11.4.7 and earlier are affected by an Improper Access Control vulnerability that could result in a Security feature bypass. A low-privileged attacker could leverage this vulnerability to bypass security measures and have a low impact on confidentiality. Exploitation of this issue does not require user interaction.

Action-Not Available
Vendor-Adobe Inc.
Product-connectAdobe Connect
CWE ID-CWE-284
Improper Access Control
CVE-2023-36638
Matching Score-4
Assigner-Fortinet, Inc.
ShareView Details
Matching Score-4
Assigner-Fortinet, Inc.
CVSS Score-4.2||MEDIUM
EPSS-0.13% / 33.50%
||
7 Day CHG~0.00%
Published-13 Sep, 2023 | 12:29
Updated-24 Sep, 2024 | 19:58
Rejected-Not Available
Known To Be Used In Ransomware Campaigns?-Not Available
KEV Added-Not Available
KEV Action Due Date-Not Available

An improper privilege management vulnerability [CWE-269] in FortiManager 7.2.0 through 7.2.2, 7.0.0 through 7.0.7, 6.4.0 through 6.4.11, 6.2 all versions, 6.0 all versions and FortiAnalyzer 7.2.0 through 7.2.2, 7.0.0 through 7.0.7, 6.4.0 through 6.4.11, 6.2 all versions, 6.0 all versions API may allow a remote and authenticated API admin user to access some system settings such as the mail server settings through the API via a stolen GUI session ID.

Action-Not Available
Vendor-Fortinet, Inc.
Product-fortianalyzerfortimanagerFortiManagerFortiAnalyzer
CWE ID-CWE-284
Improper Access Control
CVE-2023-33946
Matching Score-4
Assigner-Liferay, Inc.
ShareView Details
Matching Score-4
Assigner-Liferay, Inc.
CVSS Score-2.7||LOW
EPSS-0.13% / 33.63%
||
7 Day CHG~0.00%
Published-24 May, 2023 | 15:28
Updated-22 Oct, 2024 | 15:51
Rejected-Not Available
Known To Be Used In Ransomware Campaigns?-Not Available
KEV Added-Not Available
KEV Action Due Date-Not Available

The Object module in Liferay Portal 7.4.3.4 through 7.4.3.48, and Liferay DXP 7.4 before update 49 does properly isolate objects in difference virtual instances, which allows remote authenticated users in one virtual instance to view objects in a different virtual instance via OAuth 2 scope administration page.

Action-Not Available
Vendor-Liferay Inc.
Product-digital_experience_platformliferay_portalDXPPortal
CWE ID-CWE-284
Improper Access Control
CVE-2023-33301
Matching Score-4
Assigner-Fortinet, Inc.
ShareView Details
Matching Score-4
Assigner-Fortinet, Inc.
CVSS Score-6.5||MEDIUM
EPSS-0.13% / 33.36%
||
7 Day CHG~0.00%
Published-10 Oct, 2023 | 16:48
Updated-18 Sep, 2024 | 17:49
Rejected-Not Available
Known To Be Used In Ransomware Campaigns?-Not Available
KEV Added-Not Available
KEV Action Due Date-Not Available

An improper access control vulnerability in Fortinet FortiOS 7.2.0 - 7.2.4 and 7.4.0 allows an attacker to access a restricted resource from a non trusted host.

Action-Not Available
Vendor-Fortinet, Inc.
Product-fortiosFortiOSfortios
CWE ID-CWE-284
Improper Access Control
CVE-2023-33947
Matching Score-4
Assigner-Liferay, Inc.
ShareView Details
Matching Score-4
Assigner-Liferay, Inc.
CVSS Score-2.7||LOW
EPSS-0.13% / 33.63%
||
7 Day CHG~0.00%
Published-24 May, 2023 | 15:34
Updated-22 Oct, 2024 | 15:51
Rejected-Not Available
Known To Be Used In Ransomware Campaigns?-Not Available
KEV Added-Not Available
KEV Action Due Date-Not Available

The Object module in Liferay Portal 7.4.3.4 through 7.4.3.60, and Liferay DXP 7.4 before update 61 does not segment object definition by virtual instance in search which allows remote authenticated users in one virtual instance to view object definition from a second virtual instance by searching for the object definition.

Action-Not Available
Vendor-Liferay Inc.
Product-digital_experience_platformliferay_portalDXPPortal
CWE ID-CWE-284
Improper Access Control
CVE-2022-4087
Matching Score-4
Assigner-VulDB
ShareView Details
Matching Score-4
Assigner-VulDB
CVSS Score-2.6||LOW
EPSS-0.08% / 24.52%
||
7 Day CHG~0.00%
Published-21 Nov, 2022 | 00:00
Updated-15 Apr, 2025 | 13:12
Rejected-Not Available
Known To Be Used In Ransomware Campaigns?-Not Available
KEV Added-Not Available
KEV Action Due Date-Not Available
iPXE TLS tls.c tls_new_ciphertext information exposure

A vulnerability was found in iPXE. It has been declared as problematic. This vulnerability affects the function tls_new_ciphertext of the file src/net/tls.c of the component TLS. The manipulation of the argument pad_len leads to information exposure through discrepancy. The name of the patch is 186306d6199096b7a7c4b4574d4be8cdb8426729. It is recommended to apply a patch to fix this issue. VDB-214054 is the identifier assigned to this vulnerability.

Action-Not Available
Vendor-ipxeunspecified
Product-ipxeiPXE
CWE ID-CWE-284
Improper Access Control
CWE ID-CWE-203
Observable Discrepancy
CVE-2022-38377
Matching Score-4
Assigner-Fortinet, Inc.
ShareView Details
Matching Score-4
Assigner-Fortinet, Inc.
CVSS Score-4.1||MEDIUM
EPSS-0.12% / 31.96%
||
7 Day CHG~0.00%
Published-25 Nov, 2022 | 15:47
Updated-07 Nov, 2023 | 03:50
Rejected-Not Available
Known To Be Used In Ransomware Campaigns?-Not Available
KEV Added-Not Available
KEV Action Due Date-Not Available

An improper access control vulnerability [CWE-284] in FortiManager 7.2.0, 7.0.0 through 7.0.3, 6.4.0 through 6.4.7, 6.2.0 through 6.2.9, 6.0.0 through 6.0.11 and FortiAnalyzer 7.2.0, 7.0.0 through 7.0.3, 6.4.0 through 6.4.8, 6.2.0 through 6.2.10, 6.0.0 through 6.0.12 may allow a remote and authenticated admin user assigned to a specific ADOM to access other ADOMs information such as device information and dashboard information.

Action-Not Available
Vendor-Fortinet, Inc.
Product-fortianalyzerfortimanagerFortiManagerFortiAnalyzer
CWE ID-CWE-284
Improper Access Control
CVE-2024-48899
Matching Score-4
Assigner-Fedora Project
ShareView Details
Matching Score-4
Assigner-Fedora Project
CVSS Score-4.3||MEDIUM
EPSS-0.07% / 21.54%
||
7 Day CHG~0.00%
Published-20 Nov, 2024 | 10:25
Updated-02 Jun, 2025 | 15:36
Rejected-Not Available
Known To Be Used In Ransomware Campaigns?-Not Available
KEV Added-Not Available
KEV Action Due Date-Not Available
Moodle: idor when accessing list of course badges

A vulnerability was found in Moodle. Additional checks are required to ensure users can only fetch the list of course badges for courses that they are intended to have access to.

Action-Not Available
Vendor-Moodle Pty Ltd
Product-moodle
CWE ID-CWE-284
Improper Access Control
CWE ID-CWE-639
Authorization Bypass Through User-Controlled Key
CVE-2024-47145
Matching Score-4
Assigner-Mattermost, Inc.
ShareView Details
Matching Score-4
Assigner-Mattermost, Inc.
CVSS Score-3.1||LOW
EPSS-0.07% / 22.00%
||
7 Day CHG~0.00%
Published-26 Sep, 2024 | 08:01
Updated-26 Sep, 2024 | 18:42
Rejected-Not Available
Known To Be Used In Ransomware Campaigns?-Not Available
KEV Added-Not Available
KEV Action Due Date-Not Available
Unauthorized access on archived channels via file links

Mattermost versions 9.5.x <= 9.5.8 fail to properly authorize access to archived channels when viewing archived channels is disabled, which allows an attacker to view posts and files of archived channels via file links.

Action-Not Available
Vendor-Mattermost, Inc.
Product-mattermost_serverMattermost
CWE ID-CWE-284
Improper Access Control
CVE-2024-45735
Matching Score-4
Assigner-Splunk Inc.
ShareView Details
Matching Score-4
Assigner-Splunk Inc.
CVSS Score-4.3||MEDIUM
EPSS-0.03% / 5.50%
||
7 Day CHG~0.00%
Published-14 Oct, 2024 | 16:45
Updated-28 Feb, 2025 | 11:03
Rejected-Not Available
Known To Be Used In Ransomware Campaigns?-Not Available
KEV Added-Not Available
KEV Action Due Date-Not Available
Improper Access Control for low-privileged user in Splunk Secure Gateway App

In Splunk Enterprise versions below 9.2.3 and 9.1.6, and Splunk Secure Gateway versions on Splunk Cloud Platform versions below 3.4.259, 3.6.17, and 3.7.0, a low-privileged user that does not hold the "admin" or "power" Splunk roles can see App Key Value Store (KV Store) deployment configuration and public/private keys in the Splunk Secure Gateway App.

Action-Not Available
Vendor-Splunk LLC (Cisco Systems, Inc.)
Product-splunksplunk_cloud_platformSplunk Secure GatewaySplunk Enterprisesplunk_enterprisesplunk_secure_gateway
CWE ID-CWE-284
Improper Access Control
CVE-2024-32939
Matching Score-4
Assigner-Mattermost, Inc.
ShareView Details
Matching Score-4
Assigner-Mattermost, Inc.
CVSS Score-4.3||MEDIUM
EPSS-0.04% / 12.81%
||
7 Day CHG~0.00%
Published-22 Aug, 2024 | 06:29
Updated-23 Aug, 2024 | 16:17
Rejected-Not Available
Known To Be Used In Ransomware Campaigns?-Not Available
KEV Added-Not Available
KEV Action Due Date-Not Available
Email addresses of remote users visible in props regardless of server settings

Mattermost versions 9.9.x <= 9.9.1, 9.5.x <= 9.5.7, 9.10.x <= 9.10.0, 9.8.x <= 9.8.2, when shared channels are enabled, fail to redact remote users' original email addresses stored in user props when email addresses are otherwise configured not to be visible in the local server."

Action-Not Available
Vendor-Mattermost, Inc.
Product-mattermostMattermost
CWE ID-CWE-284
Improper Access Control
CWE ID-CWE-312
Cleartext Storage of Sensitive Information
  • Previous
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • Next
Details not found